Head over to William Shelton‘s residence to continue the case. When you pull up, Shelton will be leaving his home, bags in hand. You tell him to stop, but he tries to escape. In your chase, try to stop his car by ramming it when you are close. If you are unable to stop him on the road, it’s okay because you can get him once he stops. If you are trying to get the five-star rating on this case, be careful during your car chase; running over pedestrians is one of the fastest ways to ruin your star rating. After apprehending Shelton, head over to the Pattison residence to talk to the widow.
At the Pattison Residence, you find not only Mrs. Pattison, but her lover Leroy Sabo as well. After the cut-scene, start your questioning of Mrs. Pattison:
- Hit and run incident >> Choose “Doubt.”
- Nature of argument >> Choose “Doubt.”
- Partnership with Leroy Sabo >> Choose “Lie” and use the clue Insurance letter as evidence.
After you’re done with you questions, Mrs. Pattison asks you to leave, but oddly enough, you are supposed to go use her phone. Follow the icon on your mini-map to find the telephone in the room behind where Mrs. Pattison was sitting. The coroner is asking for you to go see him.