Levine’s Liquor
When you arrive at Levine’s Liquor, head inside and talk to the owner. He will lead you back to the victim Evelyn Summer‘s bed. Search the area for clues. On the floor next to the bed you will find a photograph and a book. There’s no clue with the photograph, but the book will give you the clue: Book. Investigate it further to find the POI: Grosvenor McCaffrey. Close to the entrance to the Evelyn’s room, is a trophy and a bowling pin. Once again, there’s no clue with the trophy, but the bowling pin will give you a new location. Between the pin and the trophy is Evelyn’s name plate. No clue here either.
After you have found these clues, it’s time to question the store owner Robbins:
- Contact with victim >> Choose “Truth.” This will give you the clue: Liquor purchase.
- Relationship with victim >> Choose “Truth.”
- Knowledge of McCaffrey >> Choose “Doubt.”
After you are done questioning Robbins, move on to your next location: Mensch’s Bar.
Mensch’s Bar
You walk into the bar and start talking to the bartender. The bartender refers you to the patrons of the bar. Go to the man sitting directly in front of you, who just happens to be Grosvenor McCaffrey. Question McCaffrey:
- Criminal history >> Choose “Doubt.”
- Relationship with victim >> Choose “Lie,” and use the clue Book as evidence. This will give you the clue: Victim last seen.
After you are done questioning McCaffrey, go back to your police car. You will be summoned back to the police station. Go there to continue the case.
Central Police Station
Head into the station and follow your partner to the basement. There will be a cut-scene where the Captain will express some doubts he has about the recent series of murders. That’s all. Head back upstairs and use the phone to find McCaffrey‘s address. Save the address for later and head over to Rawling’s Bowling Alley.
Rawling’s Bowling Alley
At the bowling alley, the lady at the counter will tell you to go talk to James Tiernan, A.K.A. Jimmy. Walk through the door on the side of the alley, the same side that the desk where you talked to the lady is on. When Tiernan sees you, he tries to flee. There’s a brief car chase, and Tiernan is taken into custody. Now, head over to McCaffrey’s Apartment.